Eichhof Brewery AS/RS Design Tested in 500+ Arena Runs

Rockwell Automation's Arena simulation software was used to test the design of a new automated storage and retrieval system at the Eichhof Brewery in Luzern, Switzerland, before construction. More than 500 runs showed that the design could meet the required pallet throughput but exposed bottlenecks in unexpected places, including a rail-guided vehicle and several elevators. The July 2014 page does not show which design changes followed, what throughput or cost the built system achieved, or any AI method.

Maintained by Peter Korpak, Lead EditorHow evidence is checked

What Eichhof Brewery was trying to fix

During the conceptual design of a new automated storage and retrieval system (AS/RS) at the Eichhof Brewery in Luzern, Switzerland, the client, main contractor, and automation equipment supplier chose to test the design by computer simulation. The equipment included a conveyor system over 250 meters long with more than 150 drive units across five levels, handling up to 1,800 pallets per day. The study aimed to measure how heavily the elevators, rail-guided vehicles, and narrow-aisle cranes were used, find bottlenecks and congestion, examine breakdowns, and test strategies to move more pallets in pairs. This follows Rockwell Automation's July 31, 2014 case study. Rockwell has since removed the page; the link is the Internet Archive copy captured January 20, 2026.

How the AS/RS was modeled in Arena

The study used Arena simulation software, including its Input and Output Analyzers, in four steps: analyze the input data, design the model concept, build the simulation model, and analyze the output data, according to Rockwell Automation. The model was split into submodels. In it, pallets leave the main level where the scanner sits, travel in pairs by two elevators to the two levels above, and feed four pick-up points for the narrow-aisle cranes. Animated statistics showed crane-usage histograms, pallet counts by section, and congestion on conveyor units and rail-guided vehicles. The runs simulated breakdowns of one of the four cranes and of elevators SF3 or SF4. Truck movements and bay allocation were not simulated. The page does not say how the model was validated.

What 500+ simulation runs found

Rockwell Automation reports more than 500 simulation runs, with these findings:

  • Throughput: the design could handle the required pallet throughput, but bottlenecks appeared at different times of day in unexpected areas, which surprised the end user and the main contractor.
  • Cranes: the narrow-aisle cranes were underutilized.
  • Bottlenecks: rail-guided vehicle QVW2 unless it can run faster; elevator SF3/4 during breakdowns of other units; elevator SF1 if it can handle only one pallet at a time.
  • Intake: one scanner is enough, but pallet-pair strategies are needed. During breakdowns, pallets from production, train, and truck areas should be handled alternately.

These are design-stage simulation findings. The page reports no design changes, measured throughput in a built system, cost, or AI method, and it offers a whitepaper that was not reviewed.

Checks to take to a simulation study

Before relying on a simulation study, ask:

  • Ask what data fed the model and how it was validated. The page lists "analysis of the input data" as the first step but gives no data source, period, or validation result.
  • Ask which scenarios were left out. This study simulated one crane and elevators SF3 or SF4 failing, and excluded truck movements and bay allocation. Check that your own single points of failure are covered.
  • Ask which design decisions the runs changed. The page lists findings and needed strategies but no design change, schedule effect, or avoided cost, so it cannot support a business case on its own.

For other warehouse and distribution records, see the supply chain optimization hub; for the sector, see food and beverage.

Evidence for the Eichhof Brewery AS/RS simulation

Reported simulation findings
500+ runs; cranes underused; rail vehicle and elevators flagged as bottlenecks
Directory published
Source published

Share:

Details

AI Technology
Not established by the source
Company Size
Not reported by source

Have a similar implementation?

Share your customer's AI results and link it to your vendor profile.

Submit a case study →